Moments or Memories - Hunger and the Human Species

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 7:55 PM comments (0)

A few weeks back, i stumbled upon an interesting post by Saurabh Sharma. The post centered around making the point that increasingly, people were recording mass events from their POV along with the media highlighting a 2 way (or 3 way rather) communication paradigm.



Case in point, the recently concluded Beijing Olympics where there was a 'ubiquity of cameras, video recording devices, and mobile phones as the teams starting marching in.' With the prevelance of communication devices this is bound to happen since every individual wants to view an event as a 'piece of me' scenario along with the mass media scenario.



(Further fuelling this self recording spree is the fact that there are a multiplicity of social media vehicles to showcase these seemingly 'personal' moments and gain another step on the social ladder - but thats another post altogether - must add here; saw an interesting Album Title the other day - "What happens in New York.. goes on Facebook!")






Saurabh seems to be making the point that Every performance now seems to be turning into a two way show, that which is being watched and that which is being watched by those who are being watched. I think its safe to add here that its actually also being watched by the peers of those who are being watched themselves. He also noticed that people are choosing to record as much as they choose to experience the moment. He asks the question - is this a new behavior or is this something we always wanted to do but never had the tools?



I dont know if i can answer the question on a general level but on a personal level, i think recording less is a habit that has been 'learned' by me by becoming familiar with recording technology. I went to Kashmir and recorded 4 - 90 minute tapes and i will never see them again. I lost out on defining moments. Humans enjoy films and that tells me that we typically don't like to see more repetition of the same thing. We like to see less of more if you know what i mean. With new recording technologies maybe we try and capture as much as we can till we realize that we probably can't cherish it. More like the classic case of over - eating na? Or the kid who put his hand in a jar full of sweets and could never get it out.




What do you think?



The thought of multiple cameras also brings to mind a possible business model. Live streaming of events through multiple eyes using crawlers (and also bandwidth) that are probably twice as efficient as we know them today? Or to start off - just a timeline led amalgamation of multimedia content with the same tags to experience an event once its over. To the same, Saurabh adds - you could also provide a service that helps people learn the art of shooting and the joy of experiencing. Something like the recording basics, say "do not just look at the world through the lens". Or experience first, carry home later.



Do add your take on the possiblility of business models that can arise as a result of this multiple documentation.



The PC Application EcoSystem. Open - Source & the futuristic web user

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 7:51 PM comments (0)

In this post, reknowned marketeer Saurabh Sharma talks about the PC environement not having an app eco system - like the iPhone app store where applications are crafted in a way that they reflect function freed from form.



This according to him, has not happened yet because PC applications, have been dominated mainly by one software company viz. Microsoft. In the computing arena we are still carrying Microsoft influenced enterprise legacy on our shoulders.



I tended to disagree.





My response:



I think the function independent of form for PC's that you are talking about already exists. Look at the change in scenario coming about. We use so many web based apps. In my company atleast. We use Google Apps to host email (not outlook), we try using Google Docs or Zoho Docs as often as possible (not MS Office), for invoicing we use a web based invoicing tool, for Project Management we use a brilliant tool called Deskaway - it helps us simplify teamwork, it helps us manage projects, create milestones, tasks, responsibilities etc. - and it also acts like an online repository for client info (you should check it out). Then there is also slideshare on which we host our slideshows. I dont use Dreamweaver to customize my code - i do right off Wordpress. I use Wordpress/Blogger to help me convert text to code. I also use Comiqs.com to make comics and if the online version of photoshop becomes better along with my bandwidth - then il chuck the CS3 version from my laptop as well!


Point is - web based tools are making this revolution happen where multiple applications are being developed to satisfy multiple needs - almost to an extent of mass customization to the finest detail. It's fantastic.


Case in point - check out FireFox and the various Plugins - the directory and the use of some plugins is brilliant. FF has created a developer community that Apple can only dream of.




Saurabh responded by saying:


Web based application are the precursor to the freeing of function from the form in the Personal Computing Arena. I would be happy to see more of these being as mainstream enterprise solutions and everyday home applications. Part of the fact that they still do not dominate the market is perhaps to do with the fact that they are relatively new in the market and another part of it is to do with enterprise inertia to shift – the risk is bigger for a large enterprise than for a start up or home business.


Also, I am curious how the market would be in the next 10 years. Would it be still dominated by one big application software company with many 'others' competing for the rest of 10-20% of the market or could it be that the stage shifts to web based applications.


I am also curious how platforms like Firefox make money. If money is not the motive than can it becomes a mainstream business model in the future? This is something that puts me in two minds about opensource. Is it commerce or plain activism to block dominance of big players, many times suppoered on the sly by another big brother who wants to counter the current number one?




My reply:


I think your concerns with OpenSource are valid. But i think plain activism led open source is not necessarily a reality that can be supported for too long. The world is too small and the buzzworthiness of information is much higher. It takes some time before Open Source becomes consumer friendly and the people who jump on to it initially tend to be more opinionated, more experimental and i would also say a lot smarter at a certain level. They would get the news if the open source project is activism led - and if the community decides that it's fine - so be it. You cannot dictate/ change the market, can you? And i think plain activism will not work at all - the open source project has to have some tangible benefit. Only then will people look to use/ contribute. It's sort of a chain reaction, isn't it?


Pseudo open source movements today are being championed by companies such as Google, Apple, (now) Rediff and Facebook - which i think is good for their businesses and in the long run also better for consumer because one is ensured that a market is created and if consumers find something valuable, returns are reaped (although there may be imperfections and these techonomies are not as 'free' as they should be).


Also, i think developers will flock to locations and develop open source to a large extent only if they are able to answer the question 'What's in it for me' - so for example, a lot of web development companies i know have developed an app on Facebook that they seek to make viral or they have a Firefox plugin that is really useful - then these open source economies become great to showcase skills with respect to platform and customer understanding for companies (just like our respective content and idea creation companies may keep a blog etc.) and consumers also benefit. Multiple small businesses are building on each other to create an eco - system that is mutually beneficial which i think is great. My economic understanding is still not sound enough to highlight glaring pitfalls - maybe you could enlighten me on that.


This i think is also a fundamental shift in the way we think. This may sound like faff but i genuinely believe that because of the internet and the openness of the weboconomy we have become a lot more utilitarian. In terms of the monetization bit - i think it is going to become difficult for more people to monetize more things because there (has always been) but there will be more stress on the intangible value of things.


I dont know how the market would be in the next 10 years but i certainly would like to see user groups using different kind of tailor made applications by different companies. But i suspect that will not be the case, we humans are a lazy, unadventurous lot. Most of us will use many applications by the same company and a few applications here and there by smaller peripheral companies. If one of the peripheral companies becomes very popular then maybe we will use more applications by that company. We are, i think (and i hope) on the long road to multiplicity of application use. I sincerely hope, that as mankind we can shatter the idea of '3-4 big players rule a market' - especially on the web. Hopefully, better distribution channels and more emphasis on Word of Mouth online because of obvious changes in the communication eco system, economies of scope will be higher.


I cant wait for tomorrow - and i love today.





Saurabh finally summed it up by saying:



On one hand we have this huge centrifugal force of open source that is brewing diversity, enabling newer niches, getting more and more 'micro' - a dream come true for many a advanced user. And on the other hand there is the impending challenge of a basic standard or operation. A basic common ground that can integrate everything seamlessly (without making us compromise too much!). By everything I mean Internet and Mobile Applications on one side and the new genre of RFID enabled devices and static objects that would need a common grammar to relate to, so as to be able to help everything in the room (and outside) to talk to everything else.
When your shoes will talk to my friends wristwatch - we would need both of them to agree on a basic grammar for their language of communication and operation.



As computing becomes ubiquitous we would need much more interoperability and greater the interoperability the deeper perhaps would be the need for a standard. I know that this word Standard sounds too Microsoftish, but I am sure that the future would not hinge on one enterprise to dictate the 'spelling' of the new universal communication Standard.
Lot of action awaits and I am quite excited!



The Constant Observer Picks: Top Product and Technology Innovations in 2007

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 8:05 PM comments (1)

 

 

1) The Amazon Kindle: 200 Books, the size of a paperback.

 

The Good:

 

Small Size

A Model that looks to earn revenues from the service rather than the product.

Battery Life.

Does not tire the eyes while reading.

 

 

The Bad:

Design

Does not read PDF’s

The ‘service’ can be cracked, giving users free alternatives.

 

 

2) The RFID Revolution: By tagging items and containers with tiny chips that can be interrogated wirelessly from a few metres away, companies will be able to streamline their distribution and delivery systems. RFID tags can act as wireless bar-codes on everything from cereal boxes to medicine bottles to expensive military hardware, enabling suppliers, retailers and government agencies to track inventory more efficiently and cut costs.

 

 

RFID is not new – the technology has been around for a while, 2007 was the year it’s potential use was put into use at certain places.

 

 

In the Future, RFID can possibly put into human beings, their emotions and impulses monitored and contextual marketing can be taken to the next level.

 

 

The Drawback of course is Privacy. Also, for a large scale RFID detection mechanism, large scale wireless networks need to be deployed. In India at least, we are far from that.

 

 

3) Biometrics: It’s all about uniquely recognizing humans based upon one or more intrinsic physical or behavioral traits.

 

 

Why it’s good:

Enhanced Security

 

How can it be taken to the next level:

If biometrics can identify human emotions along with identifying traits, we can expect the same level of contextual marketing that is possible with embedding RFID’s into human beings.

 

 

4) The Nintendo Wii: I spoke at length about ‘generic benefits’ that products seek to identify in my series on technological innovation – the Wii identifies that gaming is not all about graphics and appealing to the hardcore gamers.

 

The Good:

Cheaper

Easy interface

More multiplayer options

Takes gaming back to the basics without really doing so (only people who have used the Wii will understand this!)

 

 

The Bad:

Graphics – well but the graphics are good enough

 

 

5) Cheap Laptops: Rajesh Jain and Ashok Jhunjunwala have teamed up to form Novatium, a provider that hopes to pioneer the concept of a Net PC floated by Oracle’s Larry Ellison.

 

 The PC as we know it is a self-reliant machine, heaving with processing power, laden with software and stuffed with data. But in the age of broadband, it is unnecessary to house so much computing power in a box on your desk. Better to store the bulk of it on a central server, to which users can connect via the Internet.

 

 

Novatium’s PC will probably cost Rs. 2, 800 with a Rs. 399 monthly subscription.

 

 

Expect PC and hopefully Internet penetration to take off across our country.

 

 

Nigeria has also pioneered the one laptop per child policy – where a laptop costs as little as Rs. 4, 000 or $100.

 

 

6) API’s & Widgets: Application Programming Interfaces and widgets were included in Facebook, Orkut also opened up its platform to API’s. Deep integration into the social network, mass distribution etc. can lead to new opportunities that have mutual benefits. They are here to stay.

 

 

7) Social Ads: This is something else Facebook started this year to try and be worth it’s while.  Contextual Social Advertising allows advertisers to choose the key words for which it seeks to generate clicks and simultaneously gives the advertiser an idea of how many people fit the description of being likely to click on that key word. (a handy research tool for marketers and an exciting tool for advertisers to view since they anyway get the option of targeting specific audiences and now they can also know what they are looking at in terms of sheer numbers). I do confess however that the numbers can be slightly overestimated since not everyone will probably click on the links. To counter that Facebook has used a Google style fee collection method of Cost per Click (CPC) and also Cost per Thousand or Mille (CPM). 

 

For more on ROI on the Internet Walk into the World of Web Metrics. 

 

The Good:

Contextual

Social

 

The Bad:

The Numbers

 

 

8) GPS Cameras: Flickr has launched a geotagging feature on it’s website – to cut the long story short, camera manufacturers are now embedding GPS into cameras so that 1 drunken party can be differentiated from the others.

 

The Good:

Handy feature that makes photography more interactive

 

The Bad:

What bad?

 

 

All iPhone lovers, sorry the iPhone does not really figure on WATBlog’s list. Primarily because of:

No video recording

No real ‘unique’ features

Bundled with operators – against the economic idea of freedom.

 

 

If you hate us but still love the iPhone, read all about it here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

The Constant Observer Picks: WebSites to Watch Out for in 2008

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 7:54 PM comments (0)

We come to the end of 2007, well almost, having covered many of the International stories of the dot com World. For many in the dot com World, the year was dominated by mostly one story – the huge amount that Microsoft paid for a miniscule stake in Facebook. At The Constant Observer, we covered it extensively as well. We dealt with why Microsoft may have paid such a sum and also how Facebook is trying to be worth its while. There were many stores like the Facebook Beacon story (where a girl got to know that her boyfriend had purchased an engagement ring from Overstock.com before he even proposed – through Facebook!), which we stayed away from simply because they probably aren’t as relevant for our Constant Observers. That’s another thing we try really hard to do – make stories relevant to you, and we will strive to better that in 2008!

 

 

 

Well Facebook is not the only website to look out for internationally in 2008 – there are a host of them. Here they are (and also why they deserve to be looked at!):

 

1)    Facebook: Wrote about this above but the most exciting thing happening at Facebook is Social Ads. Placing ads in a social context, where people get associated with products. Also ads are finding their way into people’s ‘NewsFeeds’ – that’s another way of making brands ‘social’. This makes their purchase about 3 – 5 times more likely according to a study by Wharton Business School.

 

 

2)    Etsy.com – A place to “buy and sell all things handmade”. Amazon revolutionized online commerce and ebay revolutionized 2nd hand e – commerce, Etsy hopes to tap into  the trend of buying and selling handicrafts. This can have huge impact on the Indian Cottage Industries as well, expect a lot of Indian Internet Brokers in this space who will try and make a quick buck. Also expect a few “do gooders” who will try and give our cottage industry their due. It’s ironic that there is a mass medium for products that are supposed to be ‘niche’. That could be the only shortfall.

 

 

3)    MicroBlogging Websites Pownce and Twitter – The idea is this: text large groups simultaneously. Its similar to the “status update” on Facebook, only on a larger platform. For Twitter atleast, the messages are limited to just 140 characters and thus it is labeled as “micro”blogging. Pownce too has a message limit. Messages can be sent from phones, the Internet or IM’s. Expect a lot of conversations to happen in this space.

 

 

4)    Seesmic.com – Youtube is now a place for a lot of porn, spoofs, professional marketing videos etc. Seesmic.com hopes to recreate YouTube from its roots and in a sense recapture the sense of spirit of what YouTube originally was. It is for people who want to put video diaries on the Internet. Hopefully Seesmic will become the home for a generation of opinionated, thrill and attention seeking web surfers. P.S. We have such a guy at WAT – Aamer, our WATShow host would love Seesmic. The challenge: How to stop it from going the YouTube way?

 

 

5)    Dooplr.com – A site for frequent travelers – the site tracks where friends and colleagues are and enables them to meet up at unexpected places. The trend I see is micro social networking. Watch out for a lot of micro social networks.

 

 

6)    Instructables – Another Micro social network which helps innovators and individuals can "share what they do and how they do it, and learn from and collaborate with others." Essentially, Instructables offers a forum where users can sign up for free and post instructions using words and pictures to describe the creation of just about anything. Instructable subjects range from art to cooking to technology to the well-named category "not liable." Users can post comments or opinions regarding different Instructables, which creates a forum for discourse and creativity amongst individuals interested in particular how-to projects.

 

 

7)    Google Knol – A Wikipedia copy – the only difference is that content is created by “experts” in a subject. Will be monetized. Not a brilliant idea but  has the backing of Google so it has to be put on this list!

 

 

8)    Mozy.com – This wins my vote for ‘Most Useful’ – you can back up 2 GB worth of data for free. For unlimited amounts, the charge is $5 per month,  which is pretty steep for us Indians – but 2 GB free for now is good. Apple has it’s iDisk which does something similar but this takes the idea to all Internet users.

 

 

9)    Orkut.com – It has opened up to API’s, its going the Facebook way. There are a few changes, more security (well a little more). It’s trademark simplicity remains. The challenge will be to integrate this simplicity with API’s. I think Orkut will succeed in doing so. India’s Youth Icon and a major hit in the Less Developed World – expect a lot from Orkut.

 

 

10) LinkedIn – Not an extremely new social network, but again a micro social network which has succeeded at maintaining quality. My pick for ‘most useful Social Network’.

Technological Innovation and Leadership – The Guide to Successful Innovations (The 1st of a Many Part Series)

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 11:01 PM comments (2)


Innovation is supposedly the name of the game today for marketers and product developers alike. This series will deal with product innovations, their nature, how consumers possibly look at them and how an innovation can be successfully leveraged.

 

 

Let’s first take a look at the approach taken by firms towards innovation.

 

 

Too many firms today believe that there is a trade off between the “engineering” approach to innovation or the market driving approach to innovation and the pure market driven approach to innovation.

 

 

The engineering or market driving approach basically assumes that consumers do not really know anything and as a result of that, engineers must go on “innovating” without really bothering to ask them anything.

 

 

The pure market driven approach to innovation looks at innovation from a level of customer feedback to new ideas – this often results in “me too” – not truly innovative products.

 

 

 

What ‘innovators’ and marketers fail to do often is identify generic benefits to consumers. By identifying generic benefits a firm virtually lets the consumer guide the product developer and marketer through the innovation process. For example – the generic benefit that consumers may look for with respect to social networking is that they can be an enhanced version of what they really are – a social network allows them to be cool and fun – and this will guide the innovator on a social network to have adequate applications that make the user seem more ‘cool and fun’. So you will have a ‘FunWall’ or an application that tells the user which celebrity he or she looks like (and inflates his/ her ego) – or you may even have a ‘if I was a drink I would be’ (and no matter what drink you are you are bound to sound cool!). I have picked up these examples from FaceBook and again I think this is where they have got it right – the correct innovations that identify generic benefits.

 



Btw: NEWSFEED – All Social Network Watchers – Facebook just overtook MySpace in terms of visitors to the site according to alexa.com

 

 

Innovation it must be considered is understood as something new or novel. While that may apply to technologies and the functionality of features – it does not really apply to the generic benefits – they virtually stay the same.

 

So this shows that customers may “know what they want” without really “knowing it” – great isn’t it!?

 

 

So when a customer is choosing a new technology, fundamentally he is buying a benefit.

 

Thus a technological strategy should begin with the fundamental need of customers and work with a problem solving approach, an approach that satisfies a need and improvises a benefit. Such an approach is balanced in a sense and it thus diminishes that perceived trade off between being market driven or engineering driven.

 

 

 

I hope to make this series an especially insightful, long and interactive one. Over the course of the series I will be outling certain generic benefits, certain things innovators need to keep in mind while designing new products, and also various feature trends that are the real winners because they combine generic benefits. I will also try and make the scope broader if I have the capacity.

 

 

It would be great if we can make this series conversation like – do keep asking me questions and challenge what I write so that the series can be more engaging and mutually beneficial. 

Facebook attempts to change the Social Media Marketing Scenario

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 5:42 PM comments (0)

In the past few weeks  a lot of discussion has been generated on Facebook, its valuation ($15 billion), why Microsoft has probably paid such a huge sum to acquire a minority stake, et al. Here are a few developments at Facebook  that would excite investors and social media enthusiasts alike.  Facebook tries to be worth its while.           

 

Engaging Communities in Advertising-         

Social targeting. In simple words, that means placing ads within social contexts. It’s important to note that products and services are consumed primarily within a social context. Authorities in the world of marketing are excited about social targeting because one of the main concerns for any firm is when, how and to whom they should market their products – and evidence from a recent study by Shawndra Hill, a Wharton Business School Professor suggests that social networks may be one way to answer the question of relevance. She says “We provide strong evidence that whether and how well a consumer is linked to existing customers is a powerful characteristic on which to base direct marketing decisions. Our results indicate that a firm can benefit from the use of social networks to predict the likelihood of purchasing.”. The study concludes that consumers linked to a prior customer — adopt a service at a rate three to five times greater than baseline groups.      



In addition, social networks can also be used to highlight key target audiences based on non traditional, almost psychographic kind of segmentations on the basis of interests, activities, and opinions – this is generally the shortfall of conventional segmentation and targeting. So there definitely is a lot of buzz happening on the ‘social media marketing’ scene (which WATConsult, our sister brand specializes in).            

 

Contextual Advertising on Social Networks-         

 It allows advertisers to choose the key words for which it seeks to generate clicks and simultaneously gives the advertiser an idea of how many people fit the description of being likely to click on that key word. (a handy research tool for marketers and an exciting tool for advertisers to view since they anyway get the option of targeting specific audiences and now they can also know what they are looking at in terms of sheer numbers). I do confess however that the numbers can be slightly overestimated since not everyone will probably click on the links. To counter that Facebook has used a Google style fee collection method of Cost per Click (CPC) and also Cost per Thousand or Mille (CPM).    

 

How exactly does it work? -         

To give you an idea, for advertising WATBlog on Facebook with keywords such as web, advertising, technology, blogging, India; FaceBook estimated that there are about 1,300 people who are likely to click on our link. In a sense this kind of estimate is good if delivered because in the future it will lead to added credibility in terms of accuracy for the Facebook advertising brand. Observing this also gives a sense of where advertising as a whole, and particularly web advertising is heading (if not already there) – advertising HAS to be contextual and this is the first big social network player after Google who has demonstrated that (although I am sure they learnt a lot from Google’s text book).




Niche or Mass? -         

I have to confess however, that in terms of sheer numbers, 1,300 people for all the key words we highlighted is very small – miniscule in fact. So maybe advertising on FaceBook is great for niche companies (like ours) but probably for mass companies, the numbers may not deliver , at least not in India. Also one notices that in a bid to deliver more numbers, companies may start adding more keywords to their preferences (eg. WATBlog may start to add ‘engineering’, ‘computer’ etc – basically keywords that are not clearly related to WATBlog) and this may lead to loss of contextuality (which is the core USP in the first place)  

 

Where the power lies? (Or does it?) -         

Another leaf that FaceBook has taken out of Google’s learning is that makers of ads are allowed to customize their own ads. Everything from the headline to the description. Seeing this, one is overawed with respect to the barriers to entry (or lack of them) for advertising now! Anyone can be an advertiser and the emphasis is on creating a buzz – notice now that this kind of advertising is not doing much branding. The onus of branding lies with the page that the user is clicking on. So again, to reiterate, on the internet, your web page is probably your strongest branding tool (unlike in terms of mass marketing consumption products and related categories)  

 

The Replacement for Client – Agency Meetings!  -         

One can also see that FaceBook produces real time analysis for its advertisers (very similar to Google Analytics, thus they are constantly getting feedback on their advertising. So you don’t need any client agency meetings – saves time and also this is hard core quantifiable data. Again the onus is on the advertiser as to what he makes of the insights provided to him. This is an amazing feature of the internet in general – the onus and the power lies with the consumer  (in this case FaceBook’s consumer is the advertiser) and thus the advertiser creates, dictates, and executes content. The fact that content is in the hands of the consumer is easily the biggest plus of Social 2.0 (among other things) and its great to see FaceBook bringing in its core strengths and features into monetization exercises as well – a learning for e – businesses, especially content driven e – businesses.   




What is likely to be seen in this space with respect to Facebook in India? -         

I see smaller advertisers generating a lot of traffic from Facebook especially in India and this is again due to contextuality and low barriers to entry – you need about $5 or Rs. 200 a day minimum to advertise on FaceBook (mass media in India is more than expensive. About Rs. 3.5 lakh for a 10 second TV slot on Prime time television,  a full page ad in a Newspaper is a little more expensive – I don’t know the figures so I wont speculate!) Again notice that Facebook looks to grow its ad revenues the same way that Google did! – by involving small players to pay small sums by offering them superior services.

 

That is one place where conventional advertising agencies have failed – they have  failed to tap in on clients that may have small budgets for advertising but in terms of volumes, they are a large chunk of any economic market. Thus (side tracking a bit) – conventional advertising service agencies in the future are going to have to figure out ways to service small clients in volumes (possibly using the web and their strong brand equities). This is crucial in an economy like India which is growing and slated to have a per capita income of Rs. 20 lakh by 2020 (this economy is also probably high on the table in terms of entrepreneurship – so how to service all those mushrooming small companies with a budget for marketing themselves). I see an opportunity for conventional advertising because companies like Google and Facebook are still focusing on generating that ‘Buzz’ while ignoring the branding that backs the buzz – that’s where conventional agencies can capitalize on their expertise. Scale still would remain an issue they would need to sort out.


   


            











Microsoft Pours More Steam into the (mobile) Social Networking Bandwagon!

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 5:25 PM comments (0)

I have recently written quite a bit about Facebook’s takeover by Microsoft, Facebook itself, and Social Networking as a whole.

 

 

Microsoft gives me more reason to write about them. A few days back they purchased WebFives, a Seattle based, Mobile focused, Social Networking Site for an amount that has not been disclosed to the media.

 

(I think the amount has not been disclosed because its simply not newsworthy enough – I doubt its anywhere close to Microsoft’s minority stake in Facebook!)

 

 

One also needs to note that Microsoft has not made a ‘community buy’ (‘buying’ the users who are already a part of the social network); it has only acquired the technology of WebFives. WebFives is thus slated to stop at the end of this year and their users will not migrate to wherever Microsoft take WebFives.

 

 

Part of the reason why Microsoft may have only considered a technology buyout is that webfives.com probably has as many visitors as my personal blog (actually maybe a few more but what the hell I like to feel good about myself!) according to site analytics at compete.com.

 

 

So it’s quite clear that Microsoft is going to do nothing with the WebFives brand – it will probably fade into oblivion.

 

 

I think theres a bigger reason why Microsoft acquired only the technologies of WebFives.

 

 

If one looks at it, WebFives offers all the standard Social 2.0 services such as blogging, photoshare, videoshare, slideshare, audioshare – the works. The biggest asset of WebFives however is the fact that it has a facility where content (photos, videos, audio) can be uploaded directly from the mobile phones of users.

 

 

Users who sign up for WebFives generally have an account like www.webfives.com/user (much like blogger etc). What they also have is a WAP account. WAP or Wireless Application Protocol is an open international standard for applications that use wireless communication. Its principal application is to enable access to the Internet from a mobile phone or PDA.

 

 

So essentially this indicates that Social Networking is soon going to be shared between the PC and the mobile platform. I think Microsoft may just be catching the right trend this time round because as an observer I have noticed that people like to check their social networks anytime they get an opportunity to!

 

 

One also needs to know that the quantity of conversations on social networks is steadily increasing and that is feeding the ‘I need to check my account’ mindset.

 

 

WAP has its flaws. Also, gadgets like the iPhone that make the internet surfing experience on phones great (because they have successfully been able to migrate computer based web browsers like Mac’s Safari to the mobile format) prove to be worthy competitors. So im not sure how Microsoft will use the WAP format but they surely will use the learnings that WebFives has accumulated in creating a mobile page to help in optimizing all their content (Windows Live etc.) for mobile devices. This is mandatory as social 2.0 content for mobile phones needs to be fine-tuned and presented in a different way for optimization.

 

 

I also see, the technology of WebFives being integrated into Windows Live services to strengthen their already strong offering and make it more ‘engaging’ i.e. allow members to interact more easily (which is not Windows Live’s USP).

 

 

Another interesting point to note is that WebFives has widgets that can be embedded into social networks such as Facebook, Hi5, MySpace, and very soon, Orkut.

 

 

So its quite clear that Microsoft is trying to create bridge between user generated content and Social 2.0, which is smart. Think about it, how many people who blog, actively blog on Facebook or MySpace . So there’s a void here which can be filled using the technologies of WebFives. A bridge between the 2 pillars of Social 2.0 so to speak. Flickr has already followed a similar strategy on Facebook with much success.

 

 

With such a move I also see the services of Windows Live and Facebook getting more closely related. Actually not just Facebook – all the other social networking sites as well! It seems like Windows Live will now be deeply integrated into social networks.

 

 

 

WebFives, unlike Facebook, is probably a low key investment for Microsoft, but one that holds a lot of keys for its integration and future strategy development plans in order to optimize the returns generated by web 2.0 and social 2.0. 

New Development at Facebook and the World of online advertising

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 9:00 PM comments (0)



In the past few weeks there has been a lot of discussion on Facebook, its valuation ($15 billion), why Microsoft has probably paid such a huge sum to acquire a minority stake, et al.

Here are a few developments at Facebook  that would excite investors and social media enthusiasts alike.  Facebook tries to be worth its while.

            

Engaging Communities in Advertising

-  ciSocial targeting. In simple words, that means placing ads within social contexts. It’s important to note that products and services are consumed primarily within a social context. Authorities in the world of marketing are excited about social targeting because one of the main concerns for any firm is when, how and to whom they should market their products – and evidence from a recent study by Shawndra Hill, a Wharton Business School Professor suggests that social networks may be one way to answer the question of relevance. She says "We provide strong evidence that whether and how well a consumer is linked to existing customers is a powerful characteristic on which to base direct marketing decisions. Our results indicate that a firm can benefit from the use of social networks to predict the likelihood of purchasing.". The study concludes that consumers linked to a prior customer -- adopt a service at a rate three to five times greater than baseline groups.

             

In addition, social networks can also be used to highlight key target audiences based on non traditional, almost psychographic kind of segmentations on the basis of interests, activities, and opinions – this is generally the shortfall of conventional segmentation and targeting. So there definitely is a lot of buzz happening on the ‘social media marketing’ scene (which WATConsult, the brand i work for specializes in).

    

Contextual Advertising on Social Networks

-       It allows advertisers to choose the key words for which it seeks to generate clicks and simultaneously gives the advertiser an idea of how many people fit the description of being likely to click on that key word. (a handy research tool for marketers and an exciting tool for advertisers to view since they anyway get the option of targeting specific audiences and now they can also know what they are looking at in terms of sheer numbers). I do confess however that the numbers can be slightly overestimated since not everyone will probably click on the links. To counter that Facebook has used a Google style fee collection method of Cost per Click (CPC) and also Cost per Thousand or Mille (CPM). 

 

How exactly does it work?

 

-       To give you an idea, for advertising WATBlog on Facebook with keywords such as web, advertising, technology, blogging, India; FaceBook estimated that there are about 1,300 people who are likely to click on our link. In a sense this kind of estimate is good if delivered because in the future it will lead to added credibility in terms of accuracy for the Facebook advertising brand. Observing this also gives a sense of where advertising as a whole, and particularly web advertising is heading (if not already there) – advertising HAS to be contextual and this is the first big social network player after Google who has demonstrated that (although I am sure they learnt a lot from Google’s text book).

 

 

Niche or Mass?

 

-     I I have to confess however, that in terms of sheer numbers, 1,300 people for all the key words we highlighted is very small – miniscule in fact. So maybe advertising on FaceBook is great for niche companies (like ours) but probably for mass companies, the numbers may not deliver , at least not in India. Also one notices that in a bid to deliver more numbers, companies may start adding more keywords to their preferences (eg. WATBlog may start to add ‘engineering’, ‘computer’ etc – basically keywords that are not clearly related to WATBlog) and this may lead to loss of contextuality (which is the core USP in the first place)

 

 

Where the power lies? (Or does it?)

 

-       Another leaf that FaceBook has taken out of Google’s learning is that makers of ads are allowed to customize their own ads. Everything from the headline to the description. Seeing this, one is overawed with respect to the barriers to entry (or lack of them) for advertising now! Anyone can be an advertiser and the emphasis is on creating a buzz – notice now that this kind of advertising is not doing much branding. The onus of branding lies with the page that the user is clicking on. So again, to reiterate, on the internet, your web page is probably your strongest branding tool (unlike in terms of mass marketing consumption products and related categories)

 

 

The Replacement for Client – Agency Meetings!

 

-       One can also see that FaceBook produces real time analysis for its advertisers (very similar to Google Analytics, thus they are constantly getting feedback on their advertising. So you don’t need any client agency meetings – saves time and also this is hard core quantifiable data. Again the onus is on the advertiser as to what he makes of the insights provided to him. This is an amazing feature of the internet in general – the onus and the power lies with the consumer  (in this case FaceBook’s consumer is the advertiser) and thus the advertiser creates, dictates, and executes content. The fact that content is in the hands of the consumer is easily the biggest plus of Social 2.0 (among other things) and its great to see FaceBook bringing in its core strengths and features into monetization exercises as well – a learning for e – businesses, especially content driven e – businesses.


 

 

What is likely to be seen in this space with respect to Facebook in India?

 

-       I see smaller advertisers generating a lot of traffic from Facebook especially in India and this is again due to contextuality and low barriers to entry – you need about $5 or Rs. 200 a day minimum to advertise on FaceBook (mass media in India is more than expensive. About Rs. 3.5 lakh for a 10 second TV slot on Prime time television,  a full page ad in a Newspaper is a little more expensive – I don’t know the figures so I wont speculate!) Again notice that Facebook looks to grow its ad revenues the same way that Google did! – by involving small players to pay small sums by offering them superior services. That is one place where conventional advertising agencies have failed – they have  failed to tap in on clients that may have small budgets for advertising but in terms of volumes, they are a large chunk of any economic market. Thus (side tracking a bit) – conventional advertising service agencies in the future are going to have to figure out ways to service small clients in volumes (possibly using the web and their strong brand equities). This is crucial in an economy like India which is growing and slated to have a per capita income of Rs. 20 lakh by 2020 (this economy is also probably high on the table in terms of entrepreneurship – so how to service all those mushrooming small companies with a budget for marketing themselves). I see an opportunity for conventional advertising because companies like Google and Facebook are still focusing on generating that ‘Buzz’ while ignoring the branding that backs the buzz – that’s where conventional agencies can capitalize on their expertise. Scale still would remain an issue they would need to sort out.