Broad Based Mobile Advertising Models in India

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 10:47 PM comments (0)

SMS Based Ads – Plain SMS Texts Coming as Ads and Offers. They are extremely annoying and over time users become blind-sided. Within SMS ads there are new innovations such as Click to call etc – check more on Yahoo!’s mobile advertising strategy on this video.

SMS Based Contests – Inviting responses and getting users on mailer lists and then sending out updates. While this strategy ensures some sort of engagement, the tendency is to use that database to send SMS Based Ads. Care must be taken while framing messages. (This includes framing of Short codes etc)

Branded Mobile Applications – Creating useful applications that can be branded. Without operator support this is difficult.

Display ads and Sponsorships within Mobile Applications – This is another model that could be followed especially by the bigger brands. Within applications that are viral they can sponsor certain activities. For example sponsoring IM or sending out mass IM’s within applications related to social networking that invite people to an event and hosting a branded event.

SMS Based Communities around topics that can be used to have plug a variety of brands in a portfolio discreetly. For this a platform such as SMSGupshup can be used. For example – a community on Internet in India owned by someone from Reliance could be used to plug BigAdda, The BigB Blog, Zapak, Big Maps, Big Flicks, Reliance Mobile etc. The moderator however must ensure that he gets into the trust circle of users and refrains from making it seem like spam.

Ads within Community Messages – This is again the SMS Gupshup Model where relevant ads that synergize with content being sent out by group owners are placed in messages. So the idea is to place ads within content that people like to consume. A better model than the SMS based ads model. Again people might get blindsided.

Location Based Ads on Mobile (for Search) – Ads could be sent out on mobiles when people search for locations. So nearby locations can be advertised. This virtually totally opens up the platform for anybody and everybody with a local listing to sign on.

WAP Portals & sites catered to Mobile Phones – While they are handy, they rarely have a pull effect. Noone wants to visit a branded WAP portal from their mobile phone. An effective strategy could be to use Micro sites developed specially for mobile and drive engagement.

Bluetooth Advertising – This is something that I’ve noticed in Phoenix Mills. I get messages on my phone if my Bluetooth is tuned on. Bluetooth trackers can be placed in locations where individuals spend some amount of time and only location based offers can be sent to people whose Bluetooth is on.

Voice Response Contests – Similar to SMS Contests. Simplicity for the user is greater.


Ad Sponsored Calls - Before a consumer's call connect's, a short 15 second ad can play. The advertiser can thus off set some of the consumers' call cost while creating reach, and possibly some engagement. This is generally an opt - in model.


This is by no means a comprehensive list. Please add to it. Some of the things may have slipped out of my mind.

Everyone is looking at the Whooping numbers on Mobile at this point of time. The numbers are definitely slated to grow but at the same time, one will also see that advertising on mobile will grow increasingly intrusive. It already is. With so many options and avenues available for advertising one wonders how people will react to mobile advertising. What actions will consumers take? Your guess is as good as mine.

One thing is for sure. Only content that provides value will be accepted. The Mobile is a personal, conversational medium and to get into a person’s ‘individual space’, you need to provide value and engagement. That is easier said than done. But there are avenues and means to doing that. People on the mobile are searching for content (as is true on any medium) but the line between ads and content will blur even more with the blitzkrieg of mobile advertising.

Your thoughts and opinions – extremely valued. Please feel free to share exploratory theories.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Insights on Mobile Internet in India

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 11:16 PM comments (0)

According to the latest TRAI (Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of India)figures, the number of Indians using their mobiles to login to the internet has almost doubled from 16 million to 38 million just last year. This includes both CDMA and GSM users logging on to the Internet to surf, check email etc.

 

The number of ‘active’ Internet users in India currently stands at 32.2 million. In my post on the real internet ‘user’ I pointed out the problem with the word ‘active’ and other things that may be painting a picture that’s less than accurate with respect to the number of Internet users in India.

 

If the figures of the TRAI are to be believed, then it seems like mobile internet is overtaking broadband in a big way. Again the question is how often are people logging in? How much time are they spending? What is their use experience like? What are the capabilities of the Internet vis mobile?

 

Here are a few reasons as to why the mobile internet phenomenon is likely to be more sustainable than the Internet revolution:

-       There are low start up costs and low barriers to entry. A mobile phone is relatively cheaper than a computer. So it is more accessible than a computer.

-       A mobile phone is with a person most of the time. Well a laptop can be with a person as well but the real mobility factor inherent in a laptop is minimal – especially while travelling in crowded spaces which is what a lot of our country’s socio demographic spatial scenario is like.

-       Currently, Internet on the go is not available by any players other than telecom players. They use a GPRS or a CDMA format. So there is technically no high quality broadband on the go currently available. So in a sense, the same speeds for the internet on a laptop and the internet on a mobile are technically available. One has to also keep in mind that there are higher start up costs to use the same internet that is available on a mobile phone on a laptop. It costs around Rs. 3000 to buy a USB stick which gives you access via CDMA from Reliance or Tata Indicomm. For the Airtel GPRS enabled USB’s, the cost is slightly higher. So there are obvious cost advantages for the mobile as well.

 

One of the key learning’s from the mobile Voice revolution in India is that simplicity is the key to success. With a large population, that’s not extremely literate, success initially comes if a device offers obvious benefits that are simple and easy to access.

 

In developed countries the name of the game is ‘feature richness’. That phase will come to India as well – but maybe a few years later. Initially its all about getting individuals roped in to a technological phenomenal where there are no or low ‘perceived’ barriers to entry. The access to internet via mobile must not ‘appear’ elitist. If it does the entire brand of ‘mobile internet in India’ will have an intimidating feel which is never a good thing because operators can make revenues only if they rope in more people and have them using the Internet via the mobile often. 

 

In terms of allaying such fears of the Internet being elitist I do not see much in terms of communication happening. A heartening case study in terms of a brand that’s doing a lot of good to the mobile internet scenario in India is Tata Indicomm.

 

Tata Indicomm’s cheapest mobile internet phones cost around Rs. 2, 300. They have reasonable browsing capabilities and have been taken on by consumers in a big way.  

 

Apart from offering low cost phones, Tata Indicomm now offers internet packages that are extremely reasonable. 99 Rs/- a month unlimited access. Such pricing strategies will go a long way in accelerating the growth of mobile internet in India. For mobile Internet, pricing is the key element of the marketing mix that will probably allay fears of mass users. I don’t see any other operators doing enough. Some of the plans on Airtel and Vodafone are ridiculously expensive. On the GSM operators, one can pay a monthly fee of about Rs. 500 for unlimited access. For those not willing to pay those kind of fees, the cost is about 10 paise per 10 KB. On standard mobile browsers, a site may take up to 100 KB to load. So that model, even though it seems cheap, really isn’t.

 

This takes me to my next point – the mobile internet browser.

 

One of the other innovations that may aid the spread of mobile internet in India is the mobile internet web browser. On a normal mobile web browser, as stated earlier, it may take about 100 KB to load a website. So generic web browsers are taking up a lot of bandwidth that’s not necessary and also time, which makes the use experience less effective.

Apple has gone a step ahead by releasing Safari Mini. There is also Opera Mini. Both these browsers are extremely effective in the sense that a page takes about 15 KB to load.  The problem with these browsers is that they are not effective when it comes to the installing of mobile applications which have to be installed only through the generic mobile browsers. I see this problem being resolved very soon as phone companies will probably buy out technologies that will make the use experience better for their customers or integrate their services with these web browsers.



 

Specific specialized web browsers are also really effective when it comes to the arranging of content on the mobile screen. In a sense this is one more thing that probably hook the users on and give them an incentive to browse again.

 

Infrastructure to provide high speed internet over mobile phones still remains a problem which will have to be solved soon in order to maximize the capabilities of mobile Internet. A lot of phones are now available with Wi – Fi capabilities. In the future one may see 802.16 Wi Max enabled phones as well. That’s where the real action is going to be. High speed low cost internet over mobiles.

 

This week, a premier operator (Vodafone) experienced a failure of its voice services. Click here to read more on that.

 

If the infrastructure problem is not solved, and if there is no reinvestment into latest technologies by telecom operators, one can try and optimize the use experience and the prize of handsets as much as possible – the real fruits of internet over mobile can be enjoyed only with an infrastructure that’s superior. 

The Future of Video on Demand (VoD) – European VoD market slated to grow by 30% (interesting developments in India as well!)

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 10:54 PM comments (1)

A recent report by media analysts Screen Digest reveals that by 2011, 30% of all European households will have true Video on Demand capabilities.


As stated on Wikipedia, Video on demand (VOD) systems allow users to select and watch video and clip content over a network as part of an interactive television system. VOD systems either "stream" content, allowing viewing in real time, or "download" it in which the program is brought in its entirety to a set-top box before viewing starts. The latter is more appropriately termed "store and forward". The majority of cable and telecommunication based VOD systems use the streaming approach, whereby a user buys or selects a movie or television program and it begins to play on the television set almost instantaneously.

By that definition, one can already observe that approximately 2.5 million households in India already have access to VoD facilities. These are the households that have DTH services installed for their TV’s. A miniscule 2% (India has approximately 110 million TV households) but a number that is definitely slated to grow as costs drop further and the logistical benefits of DTH are more apparent to the masses.

One looks at the history of VoD in Europe, one can see that in the early days 60% of revenues came from blockbuster movies. We expect this to be the scenario in India as well – and this is already being seen with respect to the kind of VoD services such as Tata Sky and Dish TV offer.

In 2006, revenues from blockbusters in Europe dropped to 30% and people were demanding more content related to sports. This may happen in India if people stop buying bouquets and choose to view sport related content match by match. Thus if viewers are not watching Neo Sports all day and they feel that they need it only for the match, they may pay an access fee only to watch the match live and decide to forego the entire month’s payment for Neo Sports. This kind of a strategy has also taken off in the US as well where people have less time and do not necessarily watch all the matches thus they find it useless to pay the monthly fee and it is a better option for them to pay only for the matches they watch.

 

It may seem that video on demand seems very similar to pay per view. That is because it is. The only difference between VoD and PPV is that in pay per view systems, The event is shown at the same time to everyone ordering it, as opposed to video on demand systems, which allow viewers to see the event at any time.

 

In the future, VoD services will probably generate more revenues over the internet or they may follow the current television model and be supplemented with ads. The internet though will hold an advantage because ads can be contextually sent to users keeping in mind their IP addresses. This will also gain increased relevance in India as broadband speeds further increase.

 

Looking at the Indian scenario and India’s changing environment, we have seen that companies are forming alliances and joint ventures e.g. Broadcasters are creating strategic alliances with digital networking companies and teaming up with Internet companies and wireless providers to stream programming, both over the Internet and mobile devices. Technology companies are  also creating alliances to support the expansion of digital and mobile distribution of content.

 

The future of VoD worldwide certainly seems to be showing promising signs as a result of which people have been talking about the death of cable TV and the like. In India however, the mass proliferation of these services will still take a long time.

Picture of the Day

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 10:19 PM comments (0)



Normally when you take a feature, people looking into the camera is not a good thing. I would classify this picture as a group portrait - i find the expressions quite amusing. They speak volumes.


Of Broadband Speeds, Infrastructure, Entrepreneurship, and more...

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 10:11 PM comments (0)


Have a look at the statistic below – try and find where India figures on this list that ranks countries on the basis of Average Broadband Speed.

 

 

 

Surprised? A supposed hub of International technology development does not even figure on this list. Until August 2005, India did not even have a route server. It thus  took 500 milli-seconds to transmit Internet content. Now, it takes only five milli-seconds. This shows that the picture is not all grim but the country still needs to invest heavily in Internet infrastructure so that the fruits of the boons of the Internet are tasted by the average Indian user.

 

Part of the problem lies with the fact that most of India’s bandwidth is held by 3 big players – Bharati, Reliance, and MTNL/ VSNL. So there is a tendency to maximize returns in terms of what is already held.

 

The lack of Broadband speed has direct implications on the Indian internet services industry because they are restricted in terms of innovation. While the World is now dappling in concepts such as IPTv, Software as a Service, VoIP (virtually free telephony) etc, Indian IT service providers have to contend with issues such “will the page open at all and if it does will the user be able to enjoy the services we look to offer”.

 

It must also be noted that by definition, true broadband is 256 kbps dedicated (not shared 1/8). Thus, keeping in mind the price wars and fragmented service offerings of our cable operators, one really wonders how many of us in India are actually using broadband services.

 

In the future, most, if not all applications will be Internet based. Many applications will be free, funded by advertising. I also see a growing industry for secure, paid, ad free online SAAS applications. In such a scenario, it is crucial that the government capitalizes on these growing trends and deregulates the bandwidth holdings in the country (to drive efficiency) and also invests more in ensuring higher average broadband speeds.

 

Internet in India can then truly start becoming interactive and utilitarian. I also think that higher average speeds will do a lot of good to the Indian Internet Entrepreneurs.

 

I also want to take this opportunity to draw your attention to a few facts than I got from pluGGd.in

 

-       As of August 2007, the total broadband connection in India was only 2.56 million (projected figures for 2007 = 9 million)

-       The govt.’s earlier projection was to get 3 million subscribers by 2005!

 

Again to truly generate returns from the Indian Internet Services industry, more users are needed to capitalize on the growing pool of talent that already exists. If no one wants to use the services of Tech entrepreneurs, the industry will lose then as they are more than likely to migrate to another (better paid) industry.

 

Venture Capitalists take note – you would do more good to yourselves and the industry if you invested in infrastructure technologies rather than financing clones that give innovation in India a bad name.

 

Grow the pie first; then think about taking your share!

Picture of the Day

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 9:27 PM comments (0)

I like this picture (even though its not technically sound) because it captures the essence of celebration in India.


Comments, feedbacks - always appreciated

Picture of the Day

Posted by Rahul Sethi on 10:41 PM comments (0)





















I took this during the Ganesh Visarjan this year and i think its a good picture solely because it captures a moment, outlines a contrast, and i kind of like the framing as well.

Comments, opinions - i'd love to know.